Customer Reviews
Rolling with the Punches
18 people found this review helpful.
"Whip It" is surprisingly good in spite of itself, conventional as
a sports movie yet mature in its development of character. It's
also an entertaining spectacle, which is relief for me since I've
never given much thought to women's Roller Derby (or even sports in
general, but that's a topic for another day). Drew Barrymore has
done well to hype it as her directorial debut; she proves that she
not only has the technical skills, but also the ability to move a
story along through dialogue, pacing, and emotion. Having
practically grown up in front of the camera, I think it's safe to
assume she knows a thing or two about what a film needs in order
for it to work. The first thing she did right was cast Ellen Page,
who has repeatedly demonstrated just how versatile an actress she
is.
She's no exception here. She plays seventeen-year-old Bliss
Cavendar, who was raised in a middle-of-nowhere Texas town and gets
by as a diner waitress. Her overbearing mother, Brooke (Marcia Gay
Harden), a product of a very different set of standards, pressures
Bliss into competing in beauty pageants, believing you have to make
do with what you've got when you're young and attractive. When
Bliss is made aware of a Roller Derby match in nearby Austin, she
decides to go and see what all the fuss is about. Lo and behold,
she likes what she sees. She then meets Maggie Mayhem (Kristen
Wiig), a teammate for the Hurl Scouts, and is encouraged to try out
for the team. Maggie is one of several teammates that has adopted a
clever nickname; some of the other Hurl Scouts are Smashley Simpson
(Drew Barrymore), Rosa Sparks (Eve), and the Manson Sisters
(Kristen Adolfi and Rachel Piplica).
Under the guise of taking an SAT studies class, Bliss sneaks away
to Austin every week for practice. Conflict abounds: Not only have
the Hurl Scouts never won a single game, Bliss' teammates are also
unaware that she's underage (you have to be twenty-one in order to
be considered for Roller Derby). By the time she starts
participating in matches, she develops a rivalry with Iron Maven
(Juliette Lewis), the confrontational leader of undefeated
champions of Roller Derby, the Holy Rollers. Nevertheless, Bliss
has never felt more alive. At long last, she has found something
she loves to do, and she does it with people she enjoys being
around. Eventually, she will have to find and maintain that
delicate balance between her passion, her family, and her life back
home, a process that isn't as easy as it might seem.
One could see this film just for the satisfaction of watching an
uplifting, inspirational sports film, as has been done so many
times before. For me, what made this movie so enjoyable were the
characters, most so interesting and well developed that they seemed
authentic. Bliss, for example, is willful and determined, yet not
so haughty that she only seems like a spoiled brat. There's a
remarkably tender side to her, and yes, some of it is reserved for
her mother. It would have been easy to write Brooke as a
controlling, spiteful stereotype, but all of that is
avoided--despite having unrealistic expectations and a dated ideal
of successful womanhood, she genuinely cares about her daughter,
and we sense that all throughout. The only character who poses a
bit of a problem is Bliss' father, Earl (Daniel Stern), seemingly
included just for the sake of physically and morally clashing with
his wife.
Other characters function as quirky interludes, like Bliss'
supportive best friend, Pash (Alia Shawkat), the Hurl Scouts'
eccentric coach, Razor (Andrew Wilson), and the boisterous Roller
Derby announcer, "Hot Tub" Johnny Rocket (Jimmy Fallon). The
screenplay even has room for a teen romance between Bliss and a
guitarist named Oliver (Landon Pigg), who eventually swaps his coat
for Bliss' Stryper tee shirt (which she claims is the only cool
thing her mother ever gave her). Most of these characters, the last
one especially, are expected, as is the inevitable final match
between the Hurl Scouts and the Holy Rollers. And yet, it all comes
together smoothly, making for a fun and endearing film that you'll
want to see through to the end.
The game sequences are quite effective on their own, not only
because of the well choreographed skating maneuvers, but also
because of the camerawork; every shot exploits the spectacle that
is Roller Derby, gliding in time with the actors as they zoom over
and around each other on an inclined track. Other shots reveal the
grungy feel of a Roller Derby event, from the makeshift arena to
the ramshackle benches to the screaming fans, most of whom look no
older than twenty. This is interesting in and of itself, given the
fact that, save for Bliss, all the teammates are in their early to
late thirties; one of them even has a young son. Knowing these
women are mostly in it for the love of the game, one wonders how
long Bliss can keep playing right alongside them. But if there is a
message attached to "Whip It," it has nothing to do with what the
future may or may not bring; this movie is all about living in the
now and loving every minute of it.
Whip It!product
4
Whip it good!
9 people found this review helpful.
It's official: Until further notice, I will happily see any movie
featuring Ellen Page. As in previous movies, Page does an
outstanding job in bringing her angsty teenage character to life.
This time, she's a slightly lost seventeen year old being herded
around by a pageant-passionate mother. The first glimmering that
she might have goals of her own comes when she sees roller derby
girls dropping off flyers for an upcoming event. Of course, she
sneaks out to see it using a pretext transparent to everyone but
her parents, and she is transfixed. After the show, she tells one
of the skaters, "You guys are my heroes!" The tattooed derby girl
answers, "Come to the tryout - be your own hero." And she does.
The rest follows an inspiring and hilarious season of sneaking
around the parents, doing her part to bring the last-place team to
the championship. As you might expect, the poo hits the fan when
pageant-panicked Mom finds out that her little beauty queen has
another life as Babe Ruthless. I found the parent/teen flareups
somewhat milder than realistic, but then the rapprochement was
unconvincingly minor, too.
But, if that tension had been much tenser, a lot of the movie's
core fun would have been hidden. Barrymore, in her debut role as
director, clearly had fun making this and the fun comes through in
the final product. The girl-power, be-who-you-are messages come
through without shrillness, and Page's navigation of teen
heartbreak leaves her character convincingly in the lead. One scene
near the very end, her father with hammer in hand (wait for it) was
a bit predictable, but satisfying none the less. As was the whole
movie. I don't always want a movie that takes itself too seriously.
When you want a fun bit of fluff with plenty of physical comedy,
give this one a shot. It's well worth the time spent seeing it.
-- wiredweird
Whip It!product
4
The most fun on wheels I've had all year...
3 people found this review helpful.
Much more fun than I was expecting, `Whip It' is the equivalent of
girl power personified by the coming of age inevitableness of life.
With a sharp and witty directorial debut by Drew Barrymore (who
doesn't just LOVE her?), and a great cast (seriously, this ensemble
is better than nearly every ensemble SAG chose to nominate), `Whip
It' is a whole lot of fun; period.
The film revolves around a young and awkward teenager named Bliss.
Her mother is controlling and her father avoids confrontation at
all costs. Bliss is a social outcast (as is made clear in the
opening scene, she only has one friend) who is longing for
something that makes her even slightly happy. That is when a stroke
of odd luck places her in the right place at the right time. She
catches a glimpse of happiness in the form of roller derby chicks.
After attending her first match, and officially declaring the
roller clad females her new heroes, Bliss is persuaded to try-out
for the team. She smudges her age and lies to her parents and soon
becomes the new `it' girl on the roller derby circuit.
Bliss Cavendar by day, Babe Ruthless by night.
I really like Ellen Page. I really think that she is headed places.
Between her Oscar nominated turn in `Juno', her stunning (and quite
different) turn in the previous years `Hard Candy' and now her
memorable and touching performance here she has really proven she
has range and is not just a one-trick pony (as some tried to make
claim to after her `Smart People' performance proved to be very
similar to her `Juno' one). She finds a real soul in Bliss,
exploiting (in a good way) everything that makes her, and her
alter-ego, so special.
Really, it is the acting (and Drew's brisk direction) that makes
this film a must see.
Mrs. Harden is always in top form for me and I really enjoy
watching her act, so she was a delight for me. She breathes life
into a clichéd character (very clichéd
when you think about it) and makes her feel fresh and new. Alia
Shawkat is splendid as Bliss's best friend Pash, and the nerdy
Carlo Alban is effective, even if the film isn't really interested
in him. Landon Pigg is a stock boyfriend, but he has this boyish
charm to him that makes him endearing even if he is rather
unattractive. Jimmy Fallon and Andrew Wilson really make the most
of their characters (Fallon is especially funny) and Daniel Stern
is sweet and tender as Bliss's father (the scene in the van in
particular is a subtle yet heart tugging moment of paternal
affection).
And then you have all the roller derby ladies!
Kristen Wiig, Eve, Drew Barrymore, Zoe Bell and especially Juliette
Lewis are all in top form. Wiig delivers her lines with a soft and
affectionate tone that makes her feel like a real person (and that
mother/daughter talk in the car was especially effective, endearing
without every coming over sappy and out of place for the films
humorous direction). Barrymore demoted herself to slapstick
sidekick, but she is HILARIOUS! Lewis takes the cake for me with
her ferocious take on Iron Mavon, Babe Ruthless's arch nemesis. She
appears like a stock villain in the beginning, with a little extra
kick to make her pop out at you, but as the film progresses and she
has her confrontation with Bliss you really see the other side to
this woman, and remarkably Lewis was able to evoke a real sense of
painful anger in her voice.
Like I said, this ensemble is stellar.
There are some plot holes. It strikes me as rather ridiculous to
conclude that Bliss could attend all those games without her very
strict mother ever catching on. Sure, she lied and had some alibis
in the beginning, but she was out a lot and late at night, so it
didn't really make sense. The general plot point of Bliss
alienating herself after finding something `new' seemed a little
`been there done that', as did her conflicts with her mother, but
they are forgivable. The love interest side plot was a little
predictable and kind of silly, but I like the directorial
flourishes (the love scene in the pool, while `strange', was
engaging and interesting to watch) found within it.
In the end I was very satisfied with this film. I give it a very
high B (B+ even) and strongly recommend it for any fan of the genre
or the cast. It is sweet, funky, witty and ultimately full of
enough to win you over completely.
Whip It!product
4
Blu-ray: Enjoyed it more than I expected. Solid PQ, AQ could have
been better as well as special features.
2 people found this review helpful.
Roller Derby. I can easily remember turning on the television and
watching the Los Angeles T-Birds. Personally, I didn't know if this
was a true sport or if it was like wrestling and it was just sports
entertainment. But I was hooked. Not sure if it was the blonde
women with poofy hair throwing other women out of the rink or that
one person who didn't look should be on the rink, actually kicking
butt. Needless to say, that roller derby has had its following for
decades and now here we are with a film based on a character who
takes part in roller derby competitions.
"Whip It" marks the directorial debut by actress Drew Barrymore
("E.T.", "50 First Dates", "The Wedding Singer", "Charlie's Angels"
films) and is an adaptation of the novel "Derby Girl" by Shauna
Cross, a fictionalized book of skating with the TXRD Lonestar
Rollergirls.
The independent film was released in theaters during the fall of
2009 and now makes its Blu-ray and DVD debut. The Blu-ray edition
comes with a second disc which contains a digital copy of the
film.
VIDEO & AUDIO:
"Whip It" is presented in 1080 High Definition (Widescreen 2:40:1),
AVC @ 36 MBPS. The film sports vibrant colors with the Hurl Scouts
green outfits, while amber lights shine on the roller derby rink.
You can see details in the surroundings, especially injuries ala
bloody noses to bruises. Even the tattoos on Kristen Wiig are seen
much clearly on HD. Skin tones are natural and blacks are nice and
deep. Everything is visible from the freckles of Pash, to the sweat
and tears of Bliss and the other girls during competition or the
more emotional scenes of the film. I will say that at first, I
thought this was a period film shot in the '80s but you realize
that the film focuses on Bliss living in a very small town.
There is a fine amount of grain in the film and I didn't notice any
compression artifacts, banding or any sign of DNR. A solid Blu-ray
release in terms of PQ from Fox.
As for the audio, "Whip It" is featured in English 5.1 DTS-HD MA
and Spanish, French 5.1 Dolby Digital. The film is front and center
channel driven. Dialogue and music are both crystal clear but there
is minimal use of surrounds. You can hear crowd ambiance and the
women racing on the rink and hitting the side rails and hearing the
skates but its not immersive as I would have hoped but still, the
film is not all about the roller derby and there are plenty of
dialogue scenes and music-driven scenes that are very clear, with
some songs having a nice kick of bass. A pretty interesting
soundtrack as well from '80s 38 Special's "Caught Up in You" to
music from the Ramones and the Breeders.
Subtitles are in English SDH and Spanish.
SPECIAL FEATURES:
"Whip It" comes with a digital copy of the film and comes with a
few special features:
* Deleted Scenes - (16:14) Included is an alternate opening and
eight deleted scenes.
* Fox Movie Channel Presents Writer's Draft: Shauna Cross of "Whip
It" - (3:04) A short featurette with an interview with novel and
screenwriter Shauna Cross about "Whip It".
* Whip It Soundtrack Spot - (:32) A promotional for the "Whip It"
soundtrack.
JUDGMENT CALL:
"Whip It" may seem like a film about roller derby and the antics
that go behind-the-scenes of the sport but truthfully, the film has
many layers. From a coming-of-age film, a relationship movie and a
girl power film, there are a good number of things going on in this
film that there is far much more to enjoy than expected.
I have to admit that Drew Barrymore's directorial debut definitely
shows promise. The actress has starred in so many films since she
was a child and has worked with a good number of quality
director's, I had no doubt that she would do a pretty solid
job.
Part of the challenge of "Whip It" is bringing together this wild
bunch of characters that the character Bliss associates with and
then bringing this other side of her life as a teenager from a
small town, having an overbearing pageant mother and working at a
fast food restaurant while trying to maintain her friendship with
her high school friends and then finding love. Definitely not an
easy task for Barrymore but one thing she does have is the original
author Shauna Cross involved with the screenplay and she has a
talented actress in Ellen Page in the main role.
At first glance, I didn't know if Page can pull of such a role but
as she did with "Juno" she manages to pull of Bliss very well for
"Whip It".
As for the other supporting characters, personally I don't if
roller derby lifestyles are similar to what is depicted in the
movie. As much as I do enjoy Barrymore's directorial debut, her
role as Smashley Simpson is a bit too much while I do feel Kristen
Wiig manages to pull off another solid supporting role like she has
done in "Extract" and Juliette Lewis still does a great job in
portraying the bad girl. Marcia Gay Harden and Daniel Stern (who
plays Bliss's father) also do a good job as the parents of
Bliss.
As for the Blu-ray, the picture quality for the film was very good
and the lossless audio was satisfactory but it would have been
great to have it a bit more immersive via use of the surround
channels. And it would have been great to have audio commentary by
Barrymore and Shauna Cross or even a featurette on how the talent
prepared for the film or even Behind-the-scenes footage. I felt the
special features were a bit short for this Blu-ray release. But as
for the film, "Whip It" is an entertaining, humorous and a solid
coming-of-age, feel-good style of film. And again, although roller
derby does play a big part in this film, "Whip It" is not an all
out sports movie. The film has many layers to it and fortunately,
the solid performances definitely made this film enjoyable.
Overall, "Whip It" is a solid directorial debut from Drew Barrymore
and fine performances by Ellen Page and its supporting cast makes
this film better than expected.
Whip It!product
3
ROLLER DERBY QUEEN
2 people found this review helpful.
Not all movies are made to be Oscar contenders. Many are made to
simply fill theater seats and offer solid entertainment and an
enjoyable time. More often than not, these films offer a chance to
see heroes made or characters that get the opportunity to follow
their dreams. Such is the case with WHIP IT, the directorial debut
of Drew Barrymore.
Bliss Cavender (Ellen Page) is an unenthusiastic beauty queen
contestant. Fulfilling the dreams of her mother Brooke (Marcia Gay
Harden) more than herself, Bliss does as she is told between school
and working at the local BBQ restaurant. Bliss feels nothing more
than trapped in small town Bowdeen, Texas.
While clothes shopping with her mother in Austin, Bliss happens to
see a group of girls on skates come into the store they're in.
Leaving behind a stack of flyers, Bliss picks one up to see that
these are roller derby competitors trying to promote their next
match.
Sneaking off with best friend Pash (Alia Shawkat), Bliss is totally
taken in by the whole scene. The match takes place in a converted
warehouse where emcee Johnny Rocket (Jimmy Fallon) announces the
girls as they make their way to the track. With names like Iron
Maven, Smashly Simpson and Maggie Mayhem you can tell this is no
skate in the park. The girls come out rocking and knocking, making
an impression on young Bliss. When she tells Maggie afterwards that
she is her new hero, Maggie suggests she come to practice and try
out.
Once home, Bliss begins skating once more in her Barbie skates,
remnants of times gone by. She progresses from just being able to
stand to skating through town. The day comes and she sneaks off
again for Austin just in time to try out. With more speed than most
of the rest trying out, Bliss gets her chance. Now all she has to
do is sneak off to the matches.
The girls welcome Bliss in as one of the Hurl Scouts, a losing team
that has resolved to stay in last place. But with the speed Bliss
shows them and the ribbing they take from the other squads, the
team slowly gels into a force to be reckoned with. It also makes
Bliss a target for Iron Maven (Juliette Lewis), an aging star who
wants to retain her position.
Along the way Bliss also picks up a new boyfriend. Oliver (Landon
Pigg) is a member of a band that played at one of the house parties
thrown by the team. The pair seems to connect but an upcoming tour
tosses them into the possibility of a break up.
As Bliss, now known as Babe Ruthless, moves into the world of
roller derby, she begins to distance herself from her friends. And
when her parents find out about her lies (as does her team when
it's revealed she's too young to skate without her parent's
permission), Bliss finds herself alone.
The team now has a chance at the finals. The only thing stopping
this from happening is Bliss' family. Resigned to beauty pageants
once more, Bliss heads out to a new contest, her mother's favorite,
the same night as the big contest. Is there a chance of her making
it? Come on, this is a movie folks!
Is this movie believable? No way. First off no league would put
themselves in the position of being shut down due to a teenager not
being old enough. And the chances of walking in off the street and
being better than anyone else? Slim to none. But it doesn't matter.
What matters is feeling a sense of hope for Bliss as she has that
opportunity to move beyond a life she hates into one she loves,
finding that one thing in life that makes her feel more than she
has ever before.
The acting in the film is solid, especially by Ellen Page. Changing
from the shy Bliss who enters contests at her mothers request to
becoming the young woman who makes her own decisions is fleshed out
in her performance. Page has done such a great job with various
roles in films like JUNO, HARD CANDY and even X-MEN that I'm
beginning to think she's one of the best actresses around these
days.
The supporting cast also does a great job. Barrymore takes on a
small part as one of the derby girls as does singer Eve and
stuntwoman Zoe Bell. But the one who stood out for me was Kristen
Wiig as Maggie Mayhem. Wiig is one of the series regulars on
SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE these days and what I've seen of her there is
far too over the top. But like Robin Williams when given the right
director, she comes through with a great performance as a single
mom skater who acts as surrogate mom to Bliss.
Barrymore's first outing as director shows that she can put
together a well made film. It's entertaining, fun and delivers
everything the previews said it would. As I said, this isn't Oscar
material but it is a fun film. Predictable at times but its less
about the end result and more about the path taken to get there
that makes movies like these work or fail. In this case, the movie
works. So take a couple turns around the track and give this one a
look.
Whip It!product
4
Good Movie!
2 people found this review helpful.
I really enjoyed this movie. It was not the typical sports
movie/coming of age story. Ellen Page is awesome! So is Kristin
Wig.
Whip It!product
4
WheRe iS thE rinK??
2 people found this review helpful.
I knew I would love this movie!!
I was already interested and inspired by Roller Derby and to see a
movie with a kick booty cast - I figured this was a win win. I have
to admit that I don't think guys will like this movie much, but I
hope I'm wrong!! It's very impowering and inspiring!! The music and
whole derby scene is really inviting! I highly recommend this
movie!!
A MUST SEE!!!!
Whip It!product
5
Whip It Good!
1 person found this review helpful.
WHIP IT is a very well done, quirky, surprisingly enjoyable teen
film that works for adults, too. My husband and I watched this with
our 12 ½ year old daughter, and we all liked this
movie very much. With little gore and mild sex that is more
referred to than shown, WHIP IT is definitely refreshing and
fun.
WHIP IT is the story of Bliss, a seventeen-year-old diner waitress
in a backwater town near Austin, Texas. Bliss is basically a good
girl, doing everything her overbearing mother asks, including
competing in (and often winning) beauty pageants. But Bliss really
wants to make more of her life, and to find her own path. When she
finds a flyer advertising a Roller Derby match in Austin, she and
her best friend sneak out to the big city and have an adventure.
Something about the Roller Derby and the women who compete strike a
chord in Bliss, and one of the teams invites her to try out. Before
she quite knows what is happening, Bliss makes the team and becomes
a Hurl Scout. Bliss then has many life decisions to make, each of
which has significant consequences. Can Bliss find the path that
will make her truly happy?
Ellen Page is delightful and dead on as Bliss. I really like the
heart and soul that Ellen puts into her characters. The rest of the
cast is excellent and equally talented (including director Drew
Barrymore, Marcia Gay Harden, and Kristen Wiig), but Ellen Page
truly carries this film. WHIP IT is well paced, slow and thoughtful
where appropriate, yet full of excitement and great action at the
Roller Derby. And I always like the messages from Ms. Barrymore's
films...girls can do anything. Something I definitely want to
instill in my 12 ½ year old.
WHIP IT is a unique combination of sports action, teen coming of
age, and family genres that works and works really well. It was
great evening together for my entire family, and a movie we are
still talking about. WHIP IT is HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
Whip It!product
5
Very Enjoyable...!!!!
1 person found this review helpful.
What a fine movie...As one reviewer posted, not all movies are made
to be Oscar winners, and this one has some minor flaws, but
overall, very enjoyable. Ellen Page is great in the movie. Her big
eyes and expressive face bring such a fine authenticity to her
role.
Whip It!product
5
Page is outstanding
1 person found this review helpful.
Very talented Page, does it again with a great performance. This
movie will not dissappoint. Fun to watch the derby league.
Whip It!product
5