Customer Reviews
It's not about the car....
738 people found this review helpful.
Throughout his illustrious acting career, Clint Eastwood has
delivered a series of iconic characters, such as The Man with no
name, Dirty Harry, Josie Wales, and Will Munny in Unforgiven.
Throughout his illustrious directing career he has delivered
outstanding movies such as Unforgiven, Mystic River, and Million
Dollar Baby, for which he has won five Academy Awards, for best
Picture, Best Director, and including the Irving Thalberg Life
Achievement Award.
The actors who have worked with him have been blessed with Oscar:
Gene Hackman for Unforgiven, Tim Robbins and Sean Penn for Mystic
River, Morgan Freeman and Hilary Swank for Million Dollar Baby.
In Gran Torino he both directs and acts, and delivers an acting
performance that will be remembered long after the final credits
roll, in its unique way, as memorable as any other character he has
created.
Gran Torino is the second best movie I have seen this year. Not
just for the acting, not just for the directing, but for the
storytelling, and the emotional journey on which it takes you, the
laughter, the feeling of being gripped, and its more surprising
moments.
In the opening scenes, we have the exposition of the character. We
get to know Walt Kowalski, by how people act around him, and his
seemingly hateful attitude towards people. More is conveyed through
a scowl, and a snarl than with words. When the mischievous
grandchildren go through his stuff in the basement, we see the
Silver Star he won in Korea. There are three other important
symbols in the movie, the lighter, the gun, and the car.
We see a hero with a warrior past, a patriot who fought for a cause
greater than himself. Clearly, his bigotry stems from those
experiences.
He's not just mean, he's 'get of my lawn' mean. He's Dirty Harry
'Go ahead punk, make my day!,' mean.
His dead wife's priest bugs him to hear his confession, at her
request. The priest in a way is his wife's conscience.
When he snarls down the barrel of his rifle, at the neighborhood
punk: 'I could blow your head off, and sleep like a baby,' you get
the sense that he means it.
So, with all that happens, we see the change in his decision
making, from someone reluctant to be involved in his neighbor's
affairs, and a story can turn on something as random as looking at
an empty beer cooler.
For all his faults, Walt has mature masculine character. Even
though he is a difficult father, he has taught his children
character. So, when he sees the boy next door lacks character, and
a strong male role model, he takes him under his wing, and teaches
him how to be a man.
The scenes where the boy practises Walt's high octane ball busting
banter, are the funniest in the movie. Through knowing Walt, he
makes decisions he never would have made by himself. In so doing,
Walt finds meaning and purpose, and a chance for redemption, and
the boy becomes a man.
The Academy's actor awards tend to go to actors in two types of
role:
1.Psychopath- No Country for Old Men, The Usual Suspects, There
Will Be Blood, Training Day, Silence of the Lambs.
2.Mentally Disabled, Social or Physical Handicap, overcomes great
adversity or discrimination- Shine, As Good as It Gets, A Beautiful
Mind, Ray, Scent of a Woman, Capote, Philadelphia, The Pianist, A
Beautiful Life.
Every rule has an exception. Russell Crowe in Gladiator played a
character with thematic similarities to Walt.
For a 78 year old man to direct and be lead actor in a movie of
this caliber is an achievement worthy at the very least of being
nominated for the highest award for Acting, Directing or both.
I hope you find this review helpful.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5
A Better Movie about Racism than "Crash"
154 people found this review helpful.
People react strongly to "Gran Torino," either embracing its
depiction of a flawed but heroic racist old coot, or deriding the
movie simply because its apparent political incorrectness makes
them nervous. But even if the Academy does not bestow one award on
what is probably Clint Eastwood's last movie as an actor, remember
this: "Gran Torino" is a more intelligent film on the state of race
relations today than "Crash" (a multiple Oscar winner) ever
pretended to be.
The story is about Walt Kowalski, a grizzled Korean War vet and
widower who spends his time drinking, smoking, and polishing his
1972 Ford Gran Torino, a vintage example of Detroit muscle. Because
he installed the car's steering column himself, the car represents
not only a classically American fixation on the automobile, but
also a blue-collar, pull-yourself-up-by-your-bootstraps work ethic,
one that Eastwood himself would no doubt agree with. (If for some
reason you don't believe me, read his "What I've Learned" interview
in the latest issue of Esquire.)
Kowalski mentors an aimless Hmong teenager named Thao, who is being
pressured to join his cousin's gang. This is where the "Karate Kid"
comparison comes in, which is inaccurate, partly because the
characters of "Gran Torino" exhibit considerably greater depth. The
boy who plays Thao (and in fact all of the Hmong characters) is not
a professional actor, so although his portrayal is sometimes rather
wooden, there really isn't any substitute for authenticity.
Eastwood came of age in an era when Hollywood produced war movies
using, say, a Chinese actor to portray a Japanese soldier. It's
clear from the casting of "Gran Torino" (and "Letters from Iwo
Jima," for that matter) that Eastwood prefers to do things his own
way.
Kowalski makes fun of Thao (calling him "Toad"), but also teaches
the boy how to earn an honest living. In the process, he becomes
closer to Thao's family than he is to any of his own kin, who have
degenerated into a distant, crass, materialistic clan of their own,
far removed from the values Kowalski attempted to pass on.
The steady stream of racist epithets in "Gran Torino" will cause
some people to laugh uncomfortably, others to laugh with delight,
and still another group to glare at those who are laughing.
Ultimately, however, this unsettling portrayal of one man's deep
prejudices evolves into a different story altogether. It is not
possible to show the audience a path away from a racist mentality
without showing honestly where that mentality came from--a feat
which "Crash," in spite of its heavy-handed moralizing, never came
close to pulling off.
GRAN TORINOproduct
4
There's So Much We Can Learn from Each Other
151 people found this review helpful.
Can Clint Eastwood go wrong? After striking gold a few months ago
with the brilliant "Changeling," he releases "Gran Torino," another
one of the year's best films. What a masterful storyteller Eastwood
is, so focused on creating that perfect balance between story and
character. He doesn't disappoint with "Gran Torino," a nearly
flawless film that gives us characters we believe in and a story so
compelling that it's virtually impossible to not be absorbed by it.
What we have here is a cross-generational, cross-cultural story
about people who can learn so much from each other despite being
different. It's about regret, sadness, redemption, and growth,
which isn't to say that it's conventional or archetypal; Eastwood
plays a contemporary version of a Wise Old Man, someone who draws
on life experience to teach an undeveloped youth. What's unique is
that, regardless of what life has taught him, this Wise Old Man
still has a lot to learn.
He has a name, of course: retired Ford factory worker Walt
Kowalski. As a veteran of the Korean War, Kowalski has seen and
done a lot of things he wishes he hadn't. He's bitter, antisocial,
and politically incorrect. After his wife's funeral, we discover
that he doesn't get along too well with his sons, specifically
Mitch (Brian Haley) and his wife, Karen (Geraldine Hughes), who
seem to believe that his age automatically makes him codependent
and eligible for a spot in a retirement home. His grandchildren
don't appreciate him one bit; the granddaughter only wants his
stuff, hand-me-downs to take with her to school. They don't make
things easy for him, but then again, he doesn't make things easy
for them, either. It's a vicious cycle of resentment and
miscommunication.
As this is being established, we're introduced to a teenage boy
named Thao (Bee Vang), who lives next door to Kowalski with his
large Hmong family. He's the black sheep of his deeply traditional
family, always doing chores that the women are supposed to do.
Having no direction in life, he's pressured by his cousin,
nicknamed Spider (Doua Moua), to join his neighborhood gang. As an
act of initiation, Thao must sneak into Kowalski's garage and steal
his most prized possession: A 1972 Gran Torino. The attempt
backfires. Some time later, Spider arrives with his posse and tries
to abduct Thao. The resulting scuffle is broken up when Kowalski
points his shotgun at the gang members and demand they get off his
lawn.
Within no time at all, Kowalski's front steps are covered with
tokens of appreciation from Thao's family, none of which go
appreciated. But then Kowalski gets to know Thao's sister, Sue
(Ahney Her), a remarkably independent young woman. Quick-witted and
outgoing, she takes Kowalski's racial slurs in stride, believing
that a good man lies behind the disgruntled façade. As
he spends more time with Sue and her family, he begins to realize
that he has more in common with them that with his own family,
which, in all likelihood, scares him more than it brings him
comfort.
When Thao formally apologizes for trying to steal Kowalski's Gran
Torino, Kowalski puts him to work doing various chores, like
repainting a house and fixing gutters. Hardly a scene goes by when
he isn't verbally berating Thao, although it's obvious from the
start that he's doing it to toughen him up, to make him believe
that his life has a purpose and that he should actively be trying
to find it. Part of this involves getting Thao to talk like a man.
There's a priceless scene in which Kowalski brings Thao to a
barber, who has been sharing insults with Kowalski for a number of
years. Afterwards, Kowalski arranges for Thao to work at a
construction site; the boss, as it turns out, is the perfect man
for Thao to test his new vocabulary on. What Kowalski doesn't
realize is that he's learning just as much from Thao, especially in
matters of caring for other people. Eventually, Kowalski comes to
the conclusion that Thao and his family will never be at peace so
long as Spider and his gang are around.
The film's most fascinating character is Father Janovich
(Christopher Carley), a twenty-seven year old priest who promised
Kowalski's wife that he'd look after him upon her death and get him
to confess. Initially, Kowalski wants nothing to do with Janovich,
who gives sermons on matters of life and death yet has no real idea
what it means to face your own mortality. Kowalski knows--he served
his country in Korea. "What do you know about life?" Janovich
calmly asks. "Well," says Kowalski, "I survived the war. I got
married and had a family." There's absolutely no joy in his voice
when he says this. Gradually, he begins to appreciate Janovich; he
many not have all the answers, but at least he's willing to
listen.
The brilliance of this movie comes not from the development of the
characters, but from the way the characters interact with one
another. Virtually no one is on friendly terms at the start, but by
the end, there's an understated feeling that respect has been
earned on all sides. Kowalski refers to Thao as his friend only
once, and while it was nice to actually hear it, it still didn't
come as a surprise given everything that had been leading to that
moment. At a certain point, you just knew how Kowalski felt. "Gran
Torino" is such a wonderful film, so carefully structured, so
perfectly cast, so rewarding for the audience. To make just one
great film in a year is the mark of real talent. But to make two
great films in the same year, now that's the work of genius.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5
Powerful, emotional film that's bigger than the sum of its parts
19 people found this review helpful.
Some have criticized "Gran Torino" as being too simple, cliched and
hurt by the performances of the film's first-time actors.
But this is one of those rare movies that's bigger than the sum of
its parts. In recent years, I have yet to see a film that managed
to get both men and women to cry. And that it would provoke such
strong emotions is not evident until the last act.
It may seem simple and cliched on the surface, and while I knew
that Clint Eastwood's character Walt would eventually warm up to
his Hmong neighbors, I didn't expect that the movie would also have
me, a guy who doesn't cry at movies, wiping my eyes. And not just
once, but the three other times I saw the film at the theater. And
I heard other people crying at every viewing.
Each time I viewed it, it was just as powerful, if not more.
Walt is an old, bitter racist, who just about hates everyone,
including the young pastor who visits him regularly at the request
of Walt's late wife, and his own children and their families.
On paper, the story seems simple, but its power is hard to deny.
It's part drama, part comedy, part tale of one man's racist
surface, but as the credits roll, you realize that the power of the
movie, the emotional buttons it pushes, make this a movie that
rises above the acting, above its direction, above its script, to
make something deeper and emotionally touching than most would have
expected.
There are subtle touches and small scenes that any other director
would not have folded into the film. And they do go by like a
breeze for the most part. They'll have you laughing, smiling or
shaking your head.
And it's good that Eastwood's character does not make a complete
(and unrealistic) 360 degree turn, as you see in most American
movies.
And given what Eastwood has delivered in most of his movies, most
notably as Dirty Harry and his various Westerns, you expect a big
showdown to come, and that showdown does come, but not with the
ending you expect.
Eastwood has made powerful movies before, but this one really
seemed to touch the core of many people, across many age groups,
and racial/ethnic designations.
On a side note, Eastwood has also done what so many Hollywood
studios and filmmakers choose not to do, which is portray
Asian-Americans as regular, everyday people, living in America.
That's no small feat, as most Hollywood studios go out of their way
to not cast Asian-Americans and not show the lives of
Asian-Americans. They rather change the race of the characters,
even when they're basing a movie on a real-life story about
Asian-American people, or offer easy, ignorant stereotypes.
Eastwood only deserves credit, because it's something that should
have been done decades ago.
And while this movie may not get much kudos from the snobby critics
in the big film world, it has a emotional pull that even some
recent Eastwood movies don't have.
It may not have won any big awards, but it's a movie I plan on
watching for years to come.
GRAN TORINOproduct
4
Amazing
19 people found this review helpful.
I hope that in 30 years someone decides to remake Gran Torino.
Hopefully it will be a shot-by-shot remake like 1998's Psycho, or
maybe someone tries to do a direct homage to it, or maybe a
Japanese remake or didn't they make a Turkish version of Star Wars?
I really don't care how they remake it. I just want to prove how
masterfully Eastwood breathes life into a story that in wrong hands
could be a melodramatic mess, or a bad Sitcom.
Walt Kowalski (Eastwood) is a guy missing his decade, he still
lives in the home he raised his family in, even though the rest of
the neighborhood disappeared years ago. His home is still painted
while the homes around him fall apart. The post-war suburban
paradise that once was is long gone replaced by gangs, crime, and
the Hmong immigrants who have replaced his former white-bread
neighbors.
Kowalski has lived a life of hard work and maybe a little regret.
He's a decorated Korean War Vet, a husband who's just buried his
wife, and a father that has lost touch with his sons. Don't get him
started on his bratty Grandkids who want him to die so they get his
stuff including a sweet 1972 Gran Torino. Kowalski is a man who
poured his heart and soul into a country who doesn't need him
anymore and a family that is ready to send him off to Boca to die.
Everything changes when he catches his neighbor trying to steal his
Gran Torino, and he is introduced into a world that just might let
him get the redemption he so desperately needs.
Eastwood has crafted a beautiful film that is honest. With an
approach that is so matter of fact and never over sentimental. In
the wrong hands this could translate as boring. Yet Eastwood finds
a way to make the film real without boring us. It's funny when it
needs to be funny, gripping when it needs to grip, and emotional
without being overtly emotional. Kowalski exists in the real world,
he's abrasive, he's angry, he drinks, smokes, chews tobacco and has
lived long enough to not have that politically correct filter that
everyone in my generation was issued at birth. He built the world
with his bare hands and wishes that people we're polite, kids
respected their elders, and is tired of taking crap from everyone.
But it's not because he's a monster and Eastwood instills a warmth
in Kowalski that drives the film forward.
The supporting cast works because they are real kids. Newcomer
Ahney Her deserves notice as Sue, a smart plucky kid that Kowalski
aids and Bee Vang hits the right marks as Thao, Sue's brother who
Kowalski takes under his wing. Eastwood doesn't ask for
gut-wrenching performances from these two kids, only honesty and
that's why they work. When the climax hits it's apex Eastwood
doesn't ask his cast to react as characters in a movie, but as
regular kids.
Gran Torino is not what I expected, it's not Dirty Harry meets
Grumpy Old Men. It's a powerful film that sneaks up on you and
pulls you along. At any moment it could have been shallow, at any
moment it could have been melodramatic, and at any moment we could
have hated Kowalski. Trust me there is plenty not to like about
this guy, but Eastwood shows us his frustrations, and emotions not
by acting them out, but by being real and by giving Kowalski a
warmth we don't expect.
Gran Torino makes me wish I had treasured the moments I could have
had with my Grandfather. It also challenges me to reach out even If
I don't want to. Gran Torino is not about telling a fake story
about redemption, it's about real people with real problems and how
they find within themselves the power to take responsibility for
their lives and in that they find the strength to overcome what
life has dealt them. Gran Torino will not change the world but it
may make you look at your fellow man with a little more compassion.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5
Shame On You, Academy Awards
18 people found this review helpful.
The Academy went down yet another notch in my estimation for all
but ignoring this masterpiece from the master, Clint Eastwood.
Others here have described the rich plot. The group of unknown
Vietnamese actors are PERFECTLY led by Clint Eastwood, as the
silent, grouchy, proud, imperfect, highly principled American guy
we all know--or wish we knew better. Gran Torino is poignant, at
times funny, and inspirational. It could be Clint Eastwood's career
best, Dirty Harry come full urban-American circle. Shame on you,
Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences. You goofed by
ignoring a lot of classics we all love now, and you goofed on this,
big time. (And they wonder why ratings for the Oscar show continue
to dive, year after year.)
Highly recommended.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5
Hits Close to home
20 people found this review helpful.
As I near 50 I can relate to the character of Walt played by
Eastwood in this film.
No, I don't mean I am some extreme racist.... but I do share his
disdain for the declining sense of values, morals, etiquette, honor
and other behaviours we see in our society as the ugly elements of
urban growth and the negative aspects of demographic shifts take a
grip of America.
Hey, human society has never been perfect -- there is no such thing
as the "good old days" --- but there was a time when people took
pride in their neighborhoods, were quiet and considerate of others
and you could let your children play outside all day without even
thinking or worrying about street gangs or pedophiles attacking
them.
I watched GRAN TORINO with a group of people all over the age of
40, and at various times during the movie we each commented ....
"Hey' that's me".
This revelation was not one of astonishment but one of sadness as
we all agreed that the USA today sure isn't the same place we all
grew up in the 70s and 80s.
Some watch this move and focus on Walt's character overcoming old
fashioned racist stereotypes to befriend his new neighbors.
Others also comment on the equally significant social commentary in
this film that essentially shows us that although his speech and
manners may be rough and course, Walt basically has the right view
of how America is changing for the worse.
Like Walt, it seems we have had to move every 10 years or so as the
urbanization and social decline of America gradually destroys once
good neighborhoods and sickens our society like a cancer.
This is a much better film than much of the stuff nominated for
awards this year (big surprise) and actually TELLS A STORY instead
of being mindless eye candy and CGI special effects.
Definately an addition to the DVD collection.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5
Not About the Car or Racism Either
10 people found this review helpful.
With 175 reviews to read you probably won't get around to reading
mine. But Gran Torino may just be Clint Eastwood's finest acting,
and it certainly one of the best films he's directed. It's both
iconic - building on Dirty Harry and Unforgiven - and subtle. As an
actor friend of mine once said back in the late 1970's about Clint:
"He's got one look. But boy, is it a good look."
Gran Torino is the embodiment of that statement. When Clint levels
his rifle at the scum, and says he could blow their heads off, go
in, and sleep like a baby, he's probably the only man on earth
you'd believe saying something like that. His eyes, his carriage,
his intensity.
Underneath that patented Dirty Harry glare is a performance of such
subtlety, minute inflections, and being it's virtuoso. He's like a
worn out pair of jeans, a well-oiled and used baseball mitt. Clint
Eastwood uses his entire body of work as a back drop to this
performance, and builds on it to take us along for the ride.
I'm not going to share the plot as others have so far. It's a film
about values and tradition. About accountability. Doing the right
thing - up to and including making sure his old dog is taken care
of. What's masterful about the film is that he takes what could
have been a caricature in the hands of another actor and director
and makes it believable.
Much has been made of his racist language. At first it's jarring.
It's so all encompasing and over the top in the beginning of the
film you can't help but concentrate on it. But he takes it from
Archie Bunker territory with character development and plot arc to
the point where you no longer actually hear the stupid words. You
are too focused on the man's character and who he really is. A real
racist would never have entered his neighbor's home, and certainly
wouldn't have eaten their food. The reviewer who said he's racist
because he doesn't know any other way to be is spot-on.
The Hmong cast is outstanding. I especially loved the interaction
between Walt and Grandma - two peas in a pod. Bee Vang as Tow was
solid as the boy who becomes a man. Ahney Her as Sue is the driver
of the changes in Walt. If she couldn't hold her own with Clint the
film wouldn't have worked. She does, and in the bargain, Gran
Torino is a very satisfying, impressive film.
Like Gran Torinos, and Clint Eastwood, they don't make 'em like
this anymore.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5
Made My Day
10 people found this review helpful.
This is an outstanding film, brought to us by a legend of the
industry. This movie has it all: solid acting, great characters,
cinematography, pace, and plot. This film will make you think, and
this film will make you feel.
Eastwood is simply great in the tailor-made role of Walt Kowalski.
Like any great actor, he shows you all the dimensions of his
character. At first, you think he's just a cranky old man. Then,
his bigotry is front and center. Little by little, you begin to
understand him and why he is the way he is. Before you know it, you
are identifying with, and sympathizing with, a guy who needs love
more than contempt. Of course, he does find his redemption, through
the most unilkely of people.
That Clint Eastwood is great in this film should come as no
surprise. The real surprise comes via two completely inexperienced
actors, Ahney Her as Sue, and Bee Vang as Thao. These two most
unwelcome next door neighbors help Walt find his redemption, and
give him the love and respect he gets from no one else. Sharing the
screen with Eastwood is no small task for any actor, no matter how
experienced they might be. These two rose to the occasion.
The details is this film are just perfect. The casting is
excellent, from top to bottom. Eastwood's son, daughter-in-law, and
grandaughter are played to perfection by Brian Haley, Geraldine
Hughes, and Dreama Walker. They are self-absorbed and clueless as
to the needs of Walt. Walker is the teenager you love to hate,
especially when she is lusting after Walt's prize Gran Torino in
anticipation of his ultimate death. Haley and Hughes' good scene
was when they showed up to Walt's house with what they thought were
perfect birthday gifts. The gifts of a "grabber" and a phone with
huge numbers to this man who was still so vital was tasteless. The
scene played out perfectly.
The extras and smaller parts were fantastic as well. I especially
enjoyed watching the thugs and gangbangers. They looked great and
were very believable. The locations in gritty Detroit were just
right. Whatever time Eastwood and Team spent scouting locations
really paid off.
Finally, to release this most un-PC of films in hypersensitive
Hollywood was ballsy on Eastwood's part. You will hear more racial
slurs than you thought existed. These slurs are not gratuitous;
rather, they define the Walt character and make his actions all the
more important.
Don't miss this one. Highly recommended.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5
Clint Eastwood's best ever!
11 people found this review helpful.
Clint Eastwood has absolutely outdone himself with "Gran Torino". I
was expecting another tough-guy movie but what I got was something
else entirely. Yes, the Walt Kowalski character is indeed a tough
guy, but he's so much more than just that. Gone is the
one-dimensional predictability of the "Dirty Harry" days. The
greatness of this movie is in the complexity and evolution of
Eastwood's character. He pulls it off masterfully while painting a
gritty, realistic picture of life in a rough, gang-infested
neighborhood.
For the sake of avoiding any spoilers, I won't get into a
discussion of the plot except to say that the climax of the story
was entirely unexpected. The setup certainly suggested a very
different ending. The story will appeal to a wide variety of
viewers. This is a must-see movie.
GRAN TORINOproduct
5